Gyro Jimmy's Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Gyro Jimmy's, located at 165 Voice Rd in Carle Place, NY, where Mediterranean flavors meet fresh ingredients and friendly service. Prepare to indulge in an array of mouthwatering options that celebrate Greek cuisine.

  • Gyro Plates: Choose from traditional Beef & Lamb, Chicken, Pork, or Falafel plates, all crafted with all-natural meats and fresh herbs, each priced at just $14.
  • Signature Sauces: Don’t miss the flavorful Tzatziki and Gyro Jimmy’s Secret Sauce, elevating every bite.
  • Decadent Desserts: Sweeten your visit with Baklava or Galactobouriko, both making for an irresistible end to your meal.

Customers rave about Gyro Jimmy's quality, with one claiming it rivals high-end dining. With generous portions and vibrant flavors, each visit feels like a culinary adventure. Whether you’re a first-time Greek eater or a seasoned fan, expect to leave satisfied and eager for more!

Appetizers Sauces Spreads Salads Plates Sandwiches Skepasti Sides Beverages Desserts Coffee

Appetizers

Soup

Our Traditional Egg, Lemon Soup Or Lentil

Feta

Drizzled with Olive Oil & Imported Oregano.
US$9.00

Halloumi Cypriot Goat Cheese

Grilled & Sprinkled with Imported Oregano.
US$10.00

Saganaki Imported Kefalotiri Cheese

Pan Fried & Sprinkled with Imported Oregano.
US$10.00

Spanakopita Spinach Pie

Savory Spinach and Feta in a Crispy Phyllo Dough.
US$6.00

Tiropita Cheese Pie

Savory Cheese in a Crispy Phyllo Dough.
US$6.00

Chipotle Mayo-Cup

Chipotle Mayo-Homemade
US$2.00

Garlic Cream-Cup

Whipped Yogurt, Cucumber, Dill, Garlic, Salt, EVOO
US$2.00

Gyro Jimmy's Secret Sauce-Cup

It's a Secret but it is a Mayo based sauce.
US$2.00

Tahini-Cup

Sesame Paste, Lime Juice, Vinaigrette, Salt and EVOO.
US$2.00

Tirokafteri-cup

Spicy Greek feta cheese
US$2.00

Tzatziki-cup

Yogurt, Cucumber, Dill, Garlic, Salt and EVOO.
US$2.00

Sauces

Spreads

Hummus

Chickpeas, Tahini, Garlic, Lemon Juice and EVOO.
US$7.00

Melitzanosalata

Eggplant Garlic Spread
US$7.00

Tzatziki Spread

Yogurt, Cucumber, Dill, Garlic, Salt and EVOO.
US$7.00

Tirokafteri

Spicy Whipped Greek Feta Spread.
US$7.00

Taramasalata

Whipped Fish Roe Spread.
US$7.00

Tasting Trio

Pick Any 3 spreads and enjoy with or Pita Chips!!!
US$14.00

Dakos Cretan Salad

Chopped Tomatoes, Onions, Arahova Feta, Capers. Topped with traditional Cretan Dry Bread (Rusks). Flavored with Herbs & EVOO.
US$10.00

Horiatiki (Authentic Greek Salad)

Traditional Greek Villager's Salad with Arahova Feta, Plum Tomatoes, Cucumber, Onions, Olives & EVOO.
US$9.00

Lahano Cabbage Salad

White & red cabbage served with feta in a lemon-EVOO dressing
US$9.00

Prasini Chopped Salad

Chopped Lettuce, Dill, Scallions served with EVOO.
US$9.00

Salads

Plates

Chicken Gyro - Plate

All Natural, Cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
US$14.00

Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro - Plate

All Natural Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices-sliced thin.
US$14.00

Pork Gyro - Plate

All Natural, Layered Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices.
US$14.00

Falafel - Plate

Ground Chickpea with House Blend Spices and Sauce.
US$14.00

Grilled Chicken - Plate

All Natural, Chicken Breast cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices.
US$14.00

Meatless Gyro - Plate

House made, All Natural and Vegan, cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
US$14.00

Chicken Gyro - Sandwich

All Natural, Cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
US$9.00

Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro - Sandwich

All Natural Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices-sliced thin, in a Pita!
US$9.00

Pork Gyro - Sandwich

All Natural, Layered Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices.
US$9.00

Falafel - Sandwich

Ground Chickpea with House Blend Spices and Sauce.
US$9.00

Grilled Chicken - Sandwich

All Natural, Chicken Breast cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices.
US$9.00

Meatless Gyro - Sandwich

House made, All Natural and Vegan, cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
US$9.00

Sandwiches

Skepasti

Chicken Gyro - Skepasti

All Natural, Cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices.With Our Tasty Sauce!
US$14.00

Traditional (Beef & Lamb) Gyro - Skepasti

All Natural Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices-sliced thin, in 2 Pitas and our secret sauce!
US$14.00

Pork Gyro - Skepasti

All Natural, Layered Meat, Cooked with Fresh Herbs & Spices- with Our Secret Sauce.
US$14.00

Falafel - Skepasti

Ground Chickpea with House Blend Spices and Sauce.
US$14.00

Grilled Chicken - Skepasti

All Natural, Chicken Breast cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices.
US$14.00

Meatless Gyro - Skepasti

House made, All Natural and Vegan, cooked in Fresh Herbs & Spices
US$14.00

Beet Salad

Roasted Red, Crumbled Feta and Walnuts with EVO.
US$7.00

French Fries

Fried Potato Wedges with Spices.
US$6.00

Garlic Green Beans

Sauteed Green Beans in Garlic & EVO
US$6.00

Greek Fries

Fried Potato Wedges with Spices & Feta.
US$7.00

Greek Gigantes

Giant Baked butter Beans in a Tomato base with Herbs & Spices.
US$6.00

Greek Rice Pilaf

Onions, Garlic, Fresh Lemon Juice and Herbs.
US$5.00

Greek Slaw

Cabbage mixed with Fresh Herbs & Spices, EVO & Vinaigrette.
US$6.00

Horta

Dandelion Greens with EVO & Fresh Lemon Juice.
US$7.00

Lemon Potatoes

Roasted potatoes in lemon, EVO & herbs
US$6.00

Pita Bread

Extra Pita Bread
US$2.00

Pita Chips

Our Pita Chips
US$5.00

Tomato Cucumber

Plump Tomatoes, Red Onions, Cucumbers, Oregano, EVO & Vinaigrette.
US$6.00

Soup-Large

Lentil or Egg Lemon Traditional Greek Soup
US$6.00

Sides

Beverages

Greek Coffee

Greek Coffee-2 Shots of coffee in a cup.
US$5.00

Greek Soda

Orange, Lemon-Lime, Sour Cherry (Flavors)

Soda

Coke, Diet Coke, Seltzer or Sprite.

Souroti Greek Sparkling Water

Tuvunu Mountain Tea

Greek Ice Mountain Tea with Honey and Lemon.
US$5.00

Water

Baklava

Walnuts & Honey in Philo Dough with Honey.

Galactobouriko

Greek Custard and Honey Cake.

Greek Rice Pudding
US$5.00

Greek Yogurt Parfait

Yogurt with Oats and Honey.
US$6.00

Desserts

Coffee

Frappe

Greek Ice Coffee.
US$5.00

Fredo Espresso
US$5.00

Regular / Decaf Coffee
US$2.50